You see, the way Harry phrased his question was such that he made it abundantly clear he was personally hurt. His question basically shut down the entire thread’s conversation. No one addressed him any further. In such instances arguments are not addressed, but rather the interlocutors are distracted by emotional appeals instead of arguing. The conversation is shut down. Indeed, we are in a world apparently ruled by emotivists, whom Alasdair MacIntyre described so well in After Virtue . I think Pope Francis and his predecessors model for us a way of dialogue that points the way forward. Only thus can we be freed from this tyranny.